Mark my words: It’s about more than Brexit

"To fix Britain, we need to fix and restore its constitution", writes PopCon Director, Mark Littlewood. 

 

Next week our Prime Minister will attend an EU-UK summit and extol the virtues of a “reset” in our relationship with the bloc.

In doing so, he will establish the battlelines of British politics over the next few years.

In part this is because we are about to relitigate the entire argument over Brexit. But only in part. The battlelines run deeper and further than that.

What is at stake is the question of how we wish our entire state machinery to be constructed. This is very different to the question of whether you want a “big” or a “small” state, although that remains both important and related.

Let’s start by analysing Andy Burnham’s position, in so far as we can decipher it.

The PM thinks Brexit was a mistake. He believes a modern functioning economy requires committees of experts to set the rules in virtually every area of our lives. From determining what can be labelled as “smoky bacon crisps” to deciding the maximum suction power of a vacuum cleaner, Andy Burnham wants a network of technocrats to guide us (indeed to control us). Without all of these tiny things being agreed - and universally applied - chaos and inefficiency will, apparently, be the order of the day.

In the Burnham mindset, difference is essentially seen as division. Britain having a different set of rules around products and services compared to those of our European neighbours is deeply problematic. Experts need to find the best set of regulations and then apply them universally to ensure frictionless trade.

A similar approach applies on the domestic front. By his own actions, Andy Burnham clearly believes the principal function of the Prime Minister is presentation. His main task, apparently, is to mouth inspirational pep talks. Setting policy, determining a direction of travel, providing a coherent analysis of (and prescription for) the country’s key problems…these are roles to be contracted out to the likes of Alan Milburn and Stephen Timms.

Burnham is incapable of articulating a vision of where he wants to take the country beyond mouthing platitudes about “hope in every heart” and wanting an “honest conversation” in a range of areas (without ever actually engaging in such a conversation).

Our (relatively) new Prime Minister is often said principally to rely on “memes and vibes”. This isn’t an irritating accident on his part, it’s fundamental to his world view. He sees his role as that of cheerleader, not as ringmaster. Actual, real policy decisions will be taken by experts, committees, quangos and international bodies. His role is simply to try and make you feel good about what is happening.

Lined up against this world view is an emerging consensus on the broad Right of politics (although it does have some adherents on the Left too).

This approach sees politics - and political division - as central to determining the rules. The rule of law means our judicial system should apply these, not be granted wide discretion to decide what it thinks the law should be. Expert committees should be advising ministers and must serve at their pleasure, not control budgets or issue regulations (or even “guidance” in their own right). Civil servants must serve the government of the day, not profess loyalty to some abstract constitutional principle which allows them to override or ignore the instructions of elected politicians.

On one side of the new political divide are the liberal globalists who effectively wish to take the politics out of politics and give enormous powers to individuals and bodies who are not answerable to the public.

On the other are those of us who seek a fundamental reset and restoration of core British constitutional principles, the re-emergence of a sovereign Parliament and direct accountability to the electorate for those who establish the rules we must abide by.

To some this initially sounds like a rather abstract and nebulous dividing line. Surely most people are simply interested in a pragmatic approach to a range of key issues - economic growth, taxation, effective public services, robust security, a functioning immigration system and so on.

The truth is that the ways such issues are tackled (if at all) will depend on the system of government you embrace. Britain’s recent decline has been a function of decades of embracing a technocratic, opaque and detached approach to policy-making where the will of the people is too often seen as a mere annoyance, an afterthought or both.

To fix Britain, we need to fix and restore its constitution.

Burnham’s approach - not just to the EU but across the board - is to double down on the alien approach of the last few decades and to pretend that the only thing that has gone majorly awry has been the audacity of an electorate who insisted on voting Leave.

I don’t know who will triumph in the battle over how Britain is governed. It seems to me that the forces of the status quo are awesomely powerful. On the other hand, those who have concluded that the status quo is fundamentally broken - and that we need to return to a system which basically worked - are growing in number and finding their voices.

There is everything to play for.

Keep the flag of freedom flying!